In a sweet twist of fate, Captain Bonney's Creamery has once again sailed to the top, claiming the title of the best ice cream spot in the New Bedford area for the third consecutive year. This beloved creamery, nestled at 258 New Bedford Road, is not just a treat for the taste buds but a journey through history. Named after Captain Nathaniel Bonney, a whaling captain who once owned the property, the creamery's nautical theme pays homage to its rich past, creating an enchanting atmosphere that families adore.
What makes Captain Bonney's story even more fascinating is the journey of its owner, Amber Romero. Romero's connection to the creamery began during its inaugural summer, when she worked there as an employee. After eight dedicated years, she took the helm in 2020, just as the COVID-19 pandemic hit. Romero and her team navigated these challenging times with resilience, adapting to new rules and regulations with the support of the local health department. Today, Captain Bonney's Creamery stands strong, offering over 50 premium ice cream flavors and a daily dose of charm from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., even on holidays.
As it celebrates its 15th anniversary, Captain Bonney's plans to keep the fun going with special events and seasonal delights. From a rodeo week to 'Dog Days of Summer' and creative monthly sundaes, the creamery aims to create memorable experiences rooted in local history. Romero's vision is clear: to provide not just great ice cream but a welcoming atmosphere that leaves a lasting impression.
While Captain Bonney's takes the crown, there are other worthy contenders in the New Bedford area. The Ice Cream Cottage in Fairhaven offers a delightful range of new toppings and limited-time flavors, including the mouthwatering Strawberry Cookie Crumble and Blueberry Cheesecake. Acushnet Creamery at Pier 3 provides a scenic treat by the waterfront, serving homemade ice cream and lunch favorites. For a nostalgic summer stop, The Gulf Hill Dairy Ice Cream Bucket at Apponagansett Park in South Dartmouth has been a beloved destination for generations, offering a mix of ice cream and classic favorites.
Surfside Creamery in New Bedford offers a full lineup of food and ice cream, featuring seafood delights and a wide array of ice cream flavors, sundaes, and floats. And let's not forget The Robins Nest in Rochester, a hidden gem described as a 'hole in the wall.' Despite its unassuming appearance, this shop serves wonderful food and a variety of ice cream flavors, supporting local organizations like the Rochester and Middleboro grange and the Wareham soup kitchen.
These ice cream spots are more than just places to indulge in a sweet treat; they are community hubs, each with its own unique story and charm. So, whether you're a local or just passing through, be sure to explore these delicious destinations and create your own sweet memories.
